there's our catastrophe

work is its own cure. you have to like it better than being loved.

⚑ ♀

Jun 7
this is the best theory joke that the universe has yet played on me. 
I have a lot of disconnected thoughts about names, gender, the state, and culture.  like: Murasaki Shikibu is a nickname based partly on her dad’s old job, we don’t actually know her personal name for sure, she was definitely a Fujiwara, but we don’t call her “Lady Fujiwara”.  like: japanese emperors are never referred to by their personal names in japan, and after their death they are referred to by the name of their era.  like: it’s not uncommon for monarchs to have different rules around their names than apply to the rest of the population.  like: it’s also a feature of several languages and cultures to refer to certain people never by name but only by their relationship to you, either out of taboo or less stringent convention (see: most Australian Indigenous languages) (but also see: I’ve never called my parents by their given names in my life).  like: I really enjoy that bit in Bodies that Matter where Judith Butler rips Žižek a new one for talking about names as a special form of sign in that they refer to one and only one referent and each referent has one and only one real name.  like: nuns changing their names when they take their vows.  like: women changing their names all the time.  like: the Anglicisation of names of people from non-Anglo backgrounds, often arbitrarily and nonconsensually.  like: the advocacy projects against “real name” policies from Facebook, Google+, etc, driven by women, trans people, abuse survivors, people who work under names different to their legal names (performers, many coders).  like: the “same” name pronounced and spelt differently by region and era (Elizabeth, Elísabet, Elspeth, Елизаве́та, Ἐλισάβετ, إليزابيث ,אֱלִישָׁבַע).  like: the “personality” and the coherent subject.  like: the name as a tool of state control; the problems faced by people with inconsistent names on their official documents. 

this is the best theory joke that the universe has yet played on me. 

I have a lot of disconnected thoughts about names, gender, the state, and culture.  like: Murasaki Shikibu is a nickname based partly on her dad’s old job, we don’t actually know her personal name for sure, she was definitely a Fujiwara, but we don’t call her “Lady Fujiwara”.  like: japanese emperors are never referred to by their personal names in japan, and after their death they are referred to by the name of their era.  like: it’s not uncommon for monarchs to have different rules around their names than apply to the rest of the population.  like: it’s also a feature of several languages and cultures to refer to certain people never by name but only by their relationship to you, either out of taboo or less stringent convention (see: most Australian Indigenous languages) (but also see: I’ve never called my parents by their given names in my life).  like: I really enjoy that bit in Bodies that Matter where Judith Butler rips Žižek a new one for talking about names as a special form of sign in that they refer to one and only one referent and each referent has one and only one real name.  like: nuns changing their names when they take their vows.  like: women changing their names all the time.  like: the Anglicisation of names of people from non-Anglo backgrounds, often arbitrarily and nonconsensually.  like: the advocacy projects against “real name” policies from Facebook, Google+, etc, driven by women, trans people, abuse survivors, people who work under names different to their legal names (performers, many coders).  like: the “same” name pronounced and spelt differently by region and era (Elizabeth, Elísabet, Elspeth, Елизаве́та, Ἐλισάβετ, إليزابيث ,אֱלִישָׁבַע).  like: the “personality” and the coherent subject.  like: the name as a tool of state control; the problems faced by people with inconsistent names on their official documents. 


  1. thismakesmeanxious reblogged this from besttumblr and added:
    i agree with everything y’all are saying! but i don’t understand the joke/image?
  2. hadiran reblogged this from what-was-e-schatology
  3. besttumblr reblogged this from ourcatastrophe and added:
    Yeah! Another one of Butler’s friends, Adriana Cavarero, wrote similarly wrong things about the “non-substitutability of...
  4. nodamncatnodamncradle reblogged this from what-was-e-schatology
  5. what-was-e-schatology reblogged this from ourcatastrophe
  6. ourcatastrophe posted this