there's our catastrophe

work is its own cure. you have to like it better than being loved.

⚑ ♀

Sep 20

speaking of catastrophic failure to live up to your own ideals

I’m reading the queer art of failure

there are some things I like about it and it’s a fun read but I think I’m interested in more…I dunno, positivist?…ways of rethinking failure

i.e. actually setting goals that we can fail at and accepting/celebrating that failure as the price of having real goals or being able to accept that we are often wrong*, rather than attempting to redefine our failures as successes — which is what at least half of the book is doing

I mean, how safe, how boring is that? that’s not embracing failure at all! that’s constantly moving the goalposts to avoid it

also the thing halberstam says about forgetfulness as the ideal way to explore alternative ways of being — through forgetting social norms and w/e I guess — is pretty silly/wrong

the most fruitful source of alternative ways of imagining the world I’ve found is history, remembering

if you forget, then you forget what life was like before capitalism, before patriarchy as we know it, before colonialism

there is no form of forgetting that is as complete an escape from current common-sense understandings of the world as an exploration of even very recent history

see: labour historian e.p. thompson on finding inspiration and alternatives in “the blind alleys, the lost causes, and the losers” of history

I am interested to know what you think, tumblr, but I swear to God, if someone says “ah, but maybe in being silly or wrong Halberstam is destabilising normative understandings of — ” I will delete your message before I get to the end of the sentence

*you could equally just call this “flexibility” or “risk-taking”, I guess?


  1. mediocrepresident reblogged this from ourcatastrophe and added:
    All of the above.
  2. queervirtual reblogged this from nemesissy and added:
    GURL.
  3. nemesissy reblogged this from ourcatastrophe and added:
    this is a marvelous(ly snarky and clear-headed) conversation happening at ourcatastrophe’s blog
  4. wordweeds answered: yeah
  5. ourcatastrophe reblogged this from jabwell813
  6. str-crssd reblogged this from ourcatastrophe
  7. rhizombie reblogged this from ourcatastrophe and added:
    I’ve only read a chapter of Queer Art of Failure but I’m liking this discussion quite a bit.
  8. jabwell813 reblogged this from ourcatastrophe and added:
    i shouldn’t be participating here because i didn’t read this book and wasn’t planning on it, but this conversation got...
  9. tanacetum-vulgare reblogged this from mirrortheories and added:
    I like everything about this conversation, and have nothing to add. I just want to have it on my blog.
  10. lukesimcoe answered: I LOL’d. Thanks. It’s because I used Bakhtin’s “concretly sensuous” line, isn’t it?
  11. mirrortheories reblogged this from lukesimcoe and added:
    luke sorry if this is weird but you just turned me on something fierce.
  12. lukesimcoe reblogged this from ourcatastrophe and added:
    I’ve only read snippets ofThe Queer Art of Failure (Google books!), but I feel like ourcatastrophe may be unfairly...
  13. everythingbutharleyquinn reblogged this from ourcatastrophe and added:
    properly engage with this right now except...dominates my life and I actually fucking...
  14. ourcatastrophe posted this